Succeeding in convincing the consumer in the Messy Middle.
The buying process of your prospects is rarely linear. Contrary to the simplified idea of a funnel that starts with the discovery of a product and ends with the purchase decision, the consumer actually goes through a much more complex journey. We now operate in a fragmented ecosystem, where it’s possible to juggle countless sources of information, platforms, and touchpoints before making a decision. Users hesitate, compare, read reviews, explore social media, go back and forth, and start new searches. It’s a disordered cycle, unpredictable yet crucial in shaping the final purchase decision. Google has given this reality a name: the “Messy Middle.”
What is the Messy Middle?
In 2025, and for several years now, brands have not only been competing on the quality of their products. On the contrary, the challenge is much greater. They are trying to stand out in an environment where competition is omnipresent and where online content is being renewed at a dizzying speed. Consumers are exposed to avalanches of messages, ads, and offers (often similar) that continually force them to reassess their choices.
In this context, a central question arises: what guarantees that the consumer will choose your product over a competitor’s?
The Messy Middle is a concept developed by Google to describe the reality of the online purchasing journey. Unlike the idea of a simple path from product discovery to purchase, consumers go through a complex phase of back-and-forth, hesitation, and research before making their decision.
Between the moment someone becomes aware of a need and the moment they purchase, they enter a zone of disorder. During this time, they explore different options, discover new brands, read reviews, compare prices, watch videos, or are influenced by social media. Then they evaluate the information, narrow down choices, and sometimes go back to start the process again. It’s a repetitive process influenced as much by emotions and cognitive biases as by rational factors like price or quality.
Traditionally, the customer journey was conceptualized through linear models such as the conversion funnel or the AIDA model (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action). While these frameworks worked well a few years ago, they no longer reflect reality. A consumer may discover a brand on Instagram, continue researching on Google, read reviews on forums, compare prices, and ultimately purchase in a physical store.
By studying more than 310,000 purchase decisions across different industries and analyzing billions of queries and behaviors, Google found that the phase between the initial trigger and the final purchase had become particularly complex and unpredictable. This uncertain zone, the “Messy Middle”, includes all interactions between a brand and its consumer.
How does it work?
The Messy Middle concept follows a specific psychological logic. Once a consumer becomes aware of a need, they enter an exploration phase where they gather information, discover new brands, and multiply options. This stage is characterized by curiosity and openness: the consumer wants to make sure they’ve considered every alternative.
But this openness doesn’t last forever. Soon comes the evaluation phase. Here, the user narrows their focus, comparing offers, weighing pros and cons, and moving closer to a decision. They balance rational factors with emotional ones (brand trust, perceived quality, social proof through reviews).
What makes the Messy Middle so complex is that exploration and evaluation loop together, which extends the decision cycle. A consumer may explore, evaluate, then go back to search again after being influenced by an ad or a review on social media.
What this means for brands
For businesses, the Messy Middle is both a challenge and an opportunity. It shows that purchase decisions are not simply the outcome of a predefined path. On the contrary, decisions are made within this zone of disorder where consumers hesitate, compare, and let themselves be influenced.
This means you need to be continuously present in your consumer’s mind, not only at the final purchase moment. You must ensure visibility during the exploration phase (e.g., through SEO), and reassurance during the evaluation phase (e.g., strong value propositions, credibility signals). The ability to guide customers through this disorder gives you a competitive edge.
The two fundamental behavioral modes
Google identifies two behavioral modes that are both distinct and complementary:
- Exploration: the active search for information. The consumer discovers new brands, compares offers, reads reviews, and expands their range of possibilities. This phase is driven by openness and curiosity.
- Evaluation: the focus on a smaller set of options, digging deeper into each one. The consumer compares features, pros and cons, and forms a more precise opinion.
These modes don’t follow a fixed order and may alternate several times throughout the decision process. A buying journey can stretch across weeks, months, or even years, alternating between phases of intense activity and pauses, where the purchase decision is temporarily set aside.
Purchase triggers
By analyzing consumer behaviors within the Messy Middle, Google identified six cognitive biases that strongly influence purchase decisions :
- Authority: consumers trust sources they perceive as experts or legitimate. A leading brand in an industry influences perception (e.g., Apple vs. Xiaomi).
- Availability: the impact of readily accessible or recently seen information. The more present your brand is in a consumer’s environment, the more likely they are to consider it.
- Category heuristics: the tendency to simplify complexity by creating mental categories. A consumer associates a brand with a positive or negative category that guides their decision.
- Social proof: the tendency to follow the behavior of others, especially peers. The more your customers share positive experiences, the more you gain trust from prospects.
- Reciprocity: people feel inclined to give back when they receive something. Offering free value (content, samples) creates a sense of obligation that can influence purchase decisions.
- Scarcity: the fear of missing out. Exclusive or limited-time offers trigger urgency and boost purchase intent.
The power of the Messy Middle lies in using, combining, and orchestrating these tendencies—without crossing into manipulation. The goal is to deliver a meaningful experience by relying on psychological mechanisms. It’s important to note that biases vary depending on the industry, audience profile, and purchase context. A luxury brand won’t use the same levers as a mass-market retailer.
It’s important to note that biases vary depending on the industry, audience profile, and purchase context. A luxury brand won’t use the same levers as a mass-market retailer.
Consumers don’t rely only on rational data like price or product details. Their decisions are deeply shaped by cognitive and psychological biases, often subconscious, that drive the final choice. Google highlighted six key biases that act as powerful levers for triggering purchases.
The first is category heuristics: what makes a product or service stand out from the crowd. By emphasizing differentiating features, a brand can stand out in a saturated market. Then comes the power of now: fast delivery, one-click checkout, frictionless journeys—all signals that reduce hesitation and accelerate purchase.
Social proof is another major trigger: reviews, recommendations, and testimonials build trust. In a world of constant comparison, reputation often outweighs advertising. The scarcity bias also plays a strong emotional role: limited availability or expiring offers create urgency and desire.
The authority bias strengthens trust, as consumers give more weight to brands that show expertise or endorsements. Finally, the power of free is universally effective: free shipping, extra products, or free estimates feel like bonuses that remove barriers to conversion.
What makes the Messy Middle powerful isn’t just the cycle of exploration and evaluation, but the way these psychological triggers activate at every step. Brands must guide their consumers through this disorder—not by manipulating, but by highlighting what reassures, simplifies, and inspires trust.
The Messy Middle disrupts traditional marketing approaches. It requires new tools, skills, and above all, a mindset that embraces uncertainty and unpredictability as natural parts of consumer behavior.
The Messy Middle is the perfect reflection of today’s e-commerce reality: a sometimes chaotic space full of opportunities, where consumers explore, evaluate, and hesitate before making a purchase. It is within this zone of disorder that the real race for conversion takes place. As a business, you must combine visibility, credibility, and reassurance to turn prospects into customers. This transformation won’t happen overnight and requires significant investments in technology, skills, and organization. But it will give you a competitive advantage in a landscape where consumer attention is increasingly precious and harder to capture.
Découvrez les actus de l’entreprise.
Parce que mêler plaisir, partage et travail est au cœur de notre philosophie, nous prenons toujours soin de joindre l’utile à l’agréable..
For decades, the famous conversion funnel was enough to understand and interpret consumer behavior. But in 2025, consumer habits have radically changed, in line with new consumption trends.
Today, it’s impossible to ignore the power of video content in a marketing strategy. We break it all down in our article.
With new buyer expectations and the transformation of usage patterns, B2B e-commerce has become a growth driver.
The B2B journey is more thoughtful, longer, often interrupted, but rarely insignificant. When a user adds a product to their cart, they demonstrate genuine interest in the brand and/or its product. An abandoned cart is therefore not necessarily an end in itself, but can be the beginning of a purchase intention.
Product information is vast, so how to manage, structure, and distribute it without friction ?
When we think of e-commerce, we often picture a consumer comfortably seated on their couch, placing an order from a computer or smartphone. Yet, another reality of e-commerce deserves our full attention: B2B.
Today’s professional buyers, well-informed and accustomed to seamless B2C interfaces, now expect customized purchasing journeys that are relevant, efficient, and tailored to their business needs.
The Google Core Update of June 2025, officially launched on June 30, marks a new milestone in the evolution of the search engine and organic search.
If aiming for the moon seems unrealistic, there is a strategic, more precise, and above all, much more profitable long-term approach: that of long-tail keywords.
According to the latest industry data, more than 66% of businesses say they plan to expand internationally in the coming years.
Behind the smooth interface lies a system based on machine learning, which uses entered queries to refine its responses.
Far from being just communication showcases, these social platforms are now real sales channels.
Starting June 28, 2025, new digital accessibility standards will come into effect, directly impacting e-commerce websites in France. This legal obligation no longer applies only to public platforms—private companies are now included.
In France, the RGAA consists of 106 compliance criteria grouped into 13 fundamental themes that guide the audit of your platform.
Over the past several months, Hyvä has been revealing a series of technical and strategic innovations that are set to transform the entire Adobe Commerce ecosystem.
TikTok, originally known for short, entertaining videos, has recently launched TikTok Shop, a feature that could very well redefine the rules of the e-commerce game.
Agencies, software publishers, digital experts and all players in the digital space—you’ve likely heard the news. Starting June 28, 2025, all e-commerce services will be required to comply with new digital accessibility regulations.
The Speculation Rules API allows browsers to pre-render pages that a user is likely to visit, providing a smoother and faster browsing experience.
Through the AI Tour of France, organized by Medef and Numeum, French companies shared their experiences with AI and the concrete benefits they have gained, as part of the “AI Action Summit.”
In a world where e-commerce has become a cornerstone of the global economy, B2B and B2C sales models represent two essential facets of the system.
The PIM, or Product Information Management solution, is a tool that collects your product data and integrates it directly into the most suitable format for your team, all within a single digital platform.
Design thinking is a methodology that emerged in the 1970s and gained momentum in the 1980s with applications across various sectors, including e-commerce.
The Gen-Z consists of individuals born between 1997 and 2012 and now represents a significant sector of the digital market.
Millions of internet users conduct searches every day via various search engines, whether to find answers to their questions, a restaurant, a specific item, or a schedule.
The Gorilla Club, part of ASPTT Strasbourg, is a sports section dedicated to promoting and teaching American football in Alsace.
These marketing techniques encourage buyers to complete their carts with complementary products to their initial items. Although often confused, these two sales techniques have distinct objectives and can be very effective when implemented correctly.
C2C sales, or “customer to customer,” represent a major evolution in the e-commerce landscape. In this model, individuals are the main players, using specialized sites or applications to sell and buy goods or services among themselves.
Sales funnels, known as “sales funnels” in English, refer to a technique aimed at maximizing conversion rates to sell more effectively online.
In today’s digital landscape, customer reviews—whether positive or negative—inform consumers about the quality of the products or services they are considering purchasing. Positive reviews can significantly boost sales by influencing the purchasing decisions of other consumers.
The new generation spends a lot of time on social media, which has led to the emergence of new professions, notably that of influencer or content creator.
Cross-border e-commerce has transformed the global commercial landscape. This ability to sell anywhere and anytime has significantly boosted companies’ revenues.
Nowadays, social media play a prominent role in our lives. Some use them to share their daily lives, others to spread messages, and some simply to stay in touch with their loved ones or to stay informed about the news.
ChatGPT, this new artificial intelligence tool, allows for the rapid creation of content. Launched by OpenAI in 2022, its goal is to “help by answering your questions and providing information.” Impressive, right?
Soft skills play an equally important role in the success and sustainability of your digital platform. They can transform the way you interact with your customers, your team, and your market.
Over the years, the focus on user experience (UX) and user interface (UI) has been constant, but today, we are increasingly moving towards another equally crucial concept: customer experience (CX).
Virtual Reality (VR) is a rapidly growing technology that is disrupting many sectors, including e-commerce.
Product listings are the cornerstone of the commercial strategy. They play a crucial role in converting visitors into customers as they provide detailed information about the products offered by a company. What are the key points to watch out for and the best practices to optimize them and maximize sales?
The functionalities, costs, and levels of complexity can vary from one CMS to another.
When it comes to optimizing your website’s performance, paying attention to images is a crucial yet often overlooked step.
The dynamics of e-commerce are evolving rapidly, with the primary goal of businesses being to provide an optimal customer experience to maximize conversion rates and, most importantly, sales. For the past two years, a new solution has been making waves: it’s the Hyvä solution and its Hyvä Reset theme.
In the dynamic universe of online marketing and sales, the conversion rate emerges as a key indicator, reflecting the performance and success of a strategy.
In the world of marketing, efficiency reigns supreme.
The e-commerce industry continues to grow at a rapid pace, driven by technological innovation, changes in consumer behavior, and evolving market expectations.
In a constantly evolving digital landscape, it is crucial to ensure that your website is performing well, secure, and meeting the needs of your users.
The realm of web marketing plays a central role, where the scope of digital strategy may vary, but merely existing on the web is equivalent to an active approach to online promotion.
In today’s digital era, Web Marketing has become an indispensable element for businesses aiming to expand their online product and service offerings.
In the current context of e-commerce and marketing communication, the engagement rate has become a crucial indicator for measuring user interaction and involvement with content or a brand.
The sales, that long-awaited event for consumers in search of good deals and discounts. But this event is also a major date in the calendars of e-commerce websites.
Branding and e-commerce have been continuously evolving, particularly since the expansion of the internet.
In a digital world where competition is fierce, the technical optimization of a website is a crucial element to ensure a smooth user experience, enhance performance, and strengthen its search engine ranking.
Online commerce is in constant evolution, and the security of your website, whether you are a small business or a major brand, must be a top priority. E-commerce websites handle vast amounts of data to personalize their product and service offerings, tailoring them to the needs of their target audiences.
We celebrated our third birthday last June 1st…. Yep, so soon! 🥳
With Magento 2, enhancements and new features have been introduced, thus providing businesses with optimized site management.
We recently conducted an internal study to assess our ATI4 employer brand and highlight areas for improvement.
A year ago, we hired 4 developers to join our Magento Academy. We aimed to train them to use this new technology.
Last November, ATI4 joined forces with Numéric Emploi Grand-Est to host its first Apéro Dev event.
As fans of digital technology and video games, we held our first inter-company tournament.
Over the past two years, we’ve had the opportunity to work with prestigious B2B clients, to learn and to develop.